Guild based vs faction based

[Snowreap]

I think it really depends on the faction.

if Bob and Jim are both exalted with the Dwarves, and Bob kills Jim in a dwarf town, then Bob's dwarf reputation may go down, since the dwarves don't like that kind of thing. Jim's reputation might go down too, since nobody likes a loser.

if Bob and Jim are both exalted with the Orcs, and Bob kills Jim in an orc camp, then Bob's orc reputation may go up, since Bob has clearly demonstrated his superiority over Jim in combat.

-ken